top of page
Search

Episode 14&15: Job Stress Among Temporary Workers in South Korea

Updated: Nov 23, 2018

One of the most prominent topics that is portrayed throughout the episodes 14 and 15 of “Misaeng: An Incomplete Life” is the job stress temporary employees experience in South Korea’s work environment. Even though all workers are under a lot of stress from factors such as overworking, gapjil from their superiors, and competition among themselves, temporary workers have different kind of anxiety that others do not suffer from. Unlike the permanent employees, who have chances of getting promoted based on seniority, the contract employees receive minimum wage and never get more. They receive fewer health care benefits and less unemployment insurance, and they rarely have the shield of a union (Choe, 2009).

The policy of contract employees is only beneficial to the company since they do not need to take responsibility for them. Korean non-regular workers earned only 57% as much per hour as regular workers in 2010, and their average tenure was 2.24 years compared with 8.17 years for regular workers (Park, 2016, 111). The company can fire these workers whenever they want without any compensation and this causes them to experience significantly higher job stress than regular workers. In the drama, Jang Geu-rae, who is the only temporary worker among his co-workers, does everything he can to become a regular employee. However, he faces harsh reality when he realizes that there is absolutely no chance for him to become a regular employee in One International. In episode 14, O Sang-sik tells Geu-rae that companies assess the workers based on their background, most importantly. Most workers have four years of university education, learn English abroad, and train hard to get into the company. Geu-rae, despite his excellent work performance and brilliant ideas, cannot become a regular worker due to his lack of high-level education.

The temporary workers’ high job insecurity and lack of rewards have stronger associations with poor mental health than other kinds of job stress. An extreme case is shown in the drama where O Sang-sik talks about a former employee, Lee Eun-ji, who took her own life shortly after being fired from the company. Sang-sik is devastated because he felt responsible for her. He gave her some heartfelt advices, but no matter how much effort and dedication one puts into his or her work, there is no other way if the company refuses to renew the contract. It is important for the government and organizations to improve job security and reward systems to reduce job stress among non-regular workers (Park, 2016, 111). The government is making efforts to turn the contract employees into regular employees, but the companies are going against the law for their own benefit. The employment conditions has yet to be significantly improved in Korea’s workplace.


Written By: Shirley Sion Cha

453 words according to WordCounter

Here are some discussion questions..


   1. How can the government reinforce the law to eliminate the policy of temporary employees?

2. What can be done to improve the working conditions for a contract employee? What can prevent a worker to drift from one temporary job to another?



Bibliography:

Choe, Sang-hun. “In South Korea, a New Workers’ Grievance.” The New York Times, Jul. 22, 2009. https://www.nytimes.com/2009/07/23/business/global/23temps.html

(Accessed on Nov. 16, 2018)

Park, Soo-kyung, Min-kyoung Rhee, and Michàlle Mor Barak. "Job Stress and Mental Health among Nonregular Workers in Korea: What Dimensions of Job Stress are Associated with Mental Health?" Archives of Environmental & Occupational Health 71, no. 2 (2016): 111-118.


 
 
 

6 Comments


Elliott Cheung
Elliott Cheung
Dec 12, 2018

Hey team, thanks for thinking of constructive solutions for how to protect contract workers in the context of the limitations on that system - your thoughts are really intelligent. Perhaps we could consider a kind of transitional system or probation, as Jenny has brought up? Obviously it’s not a system that one can completely eliminate, but a transitional system is one way to both protect the contract employee and minimize risks for the company.

Like

Honestly, there is nothing the government can do about it because companies are mostly privately owned. Therefore, they can do whatever they want within the company by setting their own rules like they did in One International. But I personally dislike the system of temporary workers. It just feels like they are using them for their own goods (saying they are providing them experiences) and can fire them whenever they feel like without any reason.

Like

Jenny Chang
Jenny Chang
Nov 21, 2018

The ideal solution will be to grant the temporary workers with better treatment by combatting the issues addressed above: better health care benefits and unemployment insurance, for example. However, the discrepancy between how each type of employee is treated, is unavoidable especially in a country with stratified society like South Korea — the whole point of people striving after having a stable, full-time job is to earn those limited benefits that are otherwise unavailable to other types of employees. I agree with Yuxin that the policy should be focused on protecting those workers at a more disadvantageous position, rather than eliminating the policy from the root. 


By giving these temporary workers a legitimate evaluation period after their contract is over…

Like

Rebecca Lai
Rebecca Lai
Nov 19, 2018

I do not think that the government will be able to eliminate the practice of hiring temporary workers in South Korea. This is due to the rising population issue in Korea, the nuclear family is getting smaller, and less women are willing to have children. They are unwilling to start families, or rather, start them later, because a lot of companies stigmatize against working mothers, and women in general due to their potential in being a mother. Thus, a population gap problem and the government has no choice but to have temporary workers, or foreign workers fill the void. However, I feel that the government should work towards better laws that protects temporary workers and give them more equal rights…

Like

Yuxin Yang
Yuxin Yang
Nov 19, 2018

Honestly, I do not think the government could eliminate the policy related to temporary employees. However, it would be better if the rights of temporary employees could be protected and improved. This contemporary society consists of all types of workers, including technological workers, service workers, white-collar workers, managerial workers, etc. Some of them are well-educated but some are not; some need the salary very quickly but some are not; some might be students who want to get part-time jobs but some adults need stable jobs… so I would rather say the government need to protect this disadvantaged group than just eliminate the policy, since this is a really huge group in South Korea, and if this policy is eliminated, their…

Like

© 2023 by Knoll & Walters LLP. Proudly created with Wix.com

  • LinkedIn Social Icon
  • Twitter Social Icon
  • Google+ Social Icon
bottom of page